I actually found myself in several situations where my care and kindness were met with me being taken advantage of, being manipulated, gaslighted, and betrayed. But when people are constitutionally unable to admit they’re wrong, when they cannot tolerate the very notion that they are capable of mistakes, it is because they suffer from an ego so fragile that they cannot sulk and get over it — they need to warp their very perception of reality and challenge obvious facts in order to defend their not being wrong in the first place. They only taste good when she makes them. Thanks again for such an inspirational post. And when that doesn't work, he starts to attack and belittle, and ... well you get it. He is also a recovering opioid addict in treatment for 20 years on replacement medication. I've learned that we can't control other people, no matter how logical our reasoning... we can only control ourselves and our own response to others. That is how I learned about idiotic compassion ;-). It's gotten better over the years. How did you get there? He says it is not even a matter of child custody, but rather child protection. But in a mother-child relationship, the parent does wield an amazing amount of emotional power. He actually still continues in every way possible. Why Kids Steal If your child is stealing, you'll need to determine the motivation behind the act before making a plan to deal with the behavior. I know he can't help it or is even aware of it. Parents model their behavior after their own parents (the grandparents). My husband of 20 years and I have been separated for 15 months and don't expect to reconcile - I believe he is also on the autism spectrum, even though he won't admit it. Admit the Truth to Yourself. Which will ease the depression and anxiety and increase confidence. I don't know what to do to help this man, I am afraid he will end up homeless or dead. You are so right and in a funny way. :(. When I won an argument she still insisted I apologise for the distress she felt from her mistake (like getting someone gets mad at you for something that happened in a dream they had). A sheriff deputy came to my home and told me my son had been caught shop lifting. In the article though we are talking about someone who will never admit they are wrong. This is an interesting perspective. I feel if he really wanted to work he would get a job as the unemployment rate is only 3.7%. There are times when the only way to bring down barriers is to set boundaries. He also managed to estrange my mother and I over a few years . Good for you, good for everyone close to you. What I've discovered in my adult life, both through relationship repair with family and in my work in human service is if you bring compassion to every conversation it creates a natural space for truth to show up. Once you’re able to talk to him in a calm manner, now you can approach the situation. However, I believe that just about anything can be resolved with those who can admit they are wrong – because they are open to learning and to changing. I know it's hard to stay out of it. My husband does it when things don't go his way - fortunately he has a lot of very good qualities. Winch, please get your rear in gear and keep on your editors until they stop the violating hypnotherapist. Yes, a lot of them are. They refuse to admit they are racist even when they CLEARLY are. (No such luck.) It can be tricky to say sometimes what is fierce compassion and what is one’s own ego defensiveness, so experienced teacher or guide or coach would be very helpful with that. “I Don’t Allow Men I Sleep with to Kiss Me". I guess that the perp hypnotherapist is a perfect example of psychological rigidity. Culture & Society. I remember a lot of times where I felt that there was something big inside me that I had to repress to continue with my life. We connect families with caregivers and caring companies to help you be there for the ones you love. I do not even like using the word "evidence" here because it implies some wiggle room for doubt or that they could be right, as remote as that might be. That is what we are dealing with here. When confronted, they will continue to insist or pivot to attacking anyone who tries to argue otherwise and to disparaging the sources of the contradictory information (e.g., "These labs make mistakes all the time, and besides, you can't trust a confession from another criminal! Are we going to sneer at him/her? They have him on video, the store owner saw him put the items in his pocket, we found the items in my son's room, and his friend confessed to them doing it on a dare. Could it also be that they are ego maniacs? It's been a growing problem in my marriage for some time now. He told me it was merely a difference of opinion. Drop the rope. In that case it’s best to have them sit down somewhere for a while until they’re ready. Sometimes I choose a nap first. “Your kids won’t think less of you for being wrong sometimes. I find people in my life who never admit they're wrong have fragile ego's and weak self assurance. As of now, I'd have to have one of the people at PT who knows the being tell me which gender it is. Since they live in a progressive blue state Medicaid pays for his medication regimine. ... As this is a complex and sensitive subject, I request the commenters to be civil and in good faith. Care.com provides information and tools to help care seekers and care providers connect and make informed decisions. A new theory aims to make sense of it all. When Your Child Won't Talk to You ... Don't try to prove your child wrong. Which he could get from example talking about his problems with someone he trusts, which he won't do. I believe the psychological term for this is gaslighting, now that I think about it, but I’d be interested to know if Mr. Winch would say they are still acting not out of choice. If your child lies repeatedly, it may just be a bad habit that he needs help in breaking, or it may be a sign that he can't tell right from wrong. "I found your last line interesting and very thought provoking—you found the process of owning up to your own mistakes an act of compassion for yourself. My mother lies the way the rest of us breathe. No. Create a free account with Care.com and join our community today. If you can't say, in your own heart, that you were wrong, then any apology you give will feel insincere to the recipient. It is said that in order not to break our vow of compassion we have to learn when to stop aggression and draw the line. My whole life, especially as a child I just felt so empty. My husband is a workaholic and is totally disgusted with this situation. I've been trying to stop a hypnotherapy begun without my knowledge or consent, continued over my objections, in blatant violation of the perp hypnotherapist's ethics code. LGBT Activists Won't Admit Anything's Wrong With Man Flashing Children By Chad Felix Greene October 31, 2019 There is little room for polite interpretation when the headline reads “ … Can you elaborate on that at all? When I have a conversation with my brother he will frequently say, "I was right," after he makes some claim about something. I'm noticing more and more that White supremacists have this problem. 61 Ways To Be Productive When You Work From Home, 4 Reasons to View Your Relationship from a New Perspective. It took years of healing and growth to understand that making mistakes was OK and I did not have to be the embodiment of perfection to deserve to breath the air. Making a child feel sorry doesn't work. No big deal except I can count. I feel like that's not true. He said flatly "No, there were never 15 fish. I wish this was common sense. The thing is if you ask either of them for just one particular example of something I've done, they have no answer. I think the true reason they won’t admit fault has everything to do with how they were raised. There are a few reasons that. I don't argue with fools. So you might have to take him to a Therapist of some kind. I'm an only child and grew up with my two parents. How we respond to such people is up to us. All I'm seeing is the left freaking out more and more and I truly am dumbfounded by it. It takes a truly sick individual to psychology abuse children and a targeted parent like this. One Twitter user even goes so far as to claim those who disagree with her White supremacy and Trump worship cannot substantiate their arguments against her when they disagree with her and resort to name calling instead. Tip #2: Change Your Questioning. The answer is related to their ego, their very sense-of-self. One of the big signs of whether or not your child is ready to change is whether or not he is ready to stop being the victim. I struggle in orienting how I can best interact with this person. This does not mean I do not feel shame or guilt when I create a mess, or that I do not feel upset or sad when somebody else hurts me, or that there is no need for apology, reconciliation, or restitution. My husband can be passive aggressive and not even know it. There were only 12...maybe 13". Since I understand this, I can have compassion for myself and others. You owe him NOTHING. "Owning my mistakes became a concrete demonstration of compassion and unconditional love for myself." But, when given enough time to think about what happened, the desire to make things right is born. I have been dealing with this for twenty years now. When Adult Children Won’t Talk to Their Parents May 2, 2016 April 28, 2012 by Tina Gilbertson There’s an article about estrangement on my website that gets more feedback than any article I’ve written before or since. For one thing, the wrongdoer can feel ashamed or fear repercussions. 26.6k. Example: I pointed out to my husband that we've lost some fish in the pond; there were only about 12 left out of 15. Love Languages, Gary Smalley) whether it be encouraging words, acts of service, gifts, etc., children become more open and better listeners to words. I have told him over and over that it is okay to be wrong. If your adult son or daughter won’t get a job, it’s time to make some changes. It sounds like you just need to step back and get a little distance, set some boundaries and focus on your own actions and your own immediate family (husband, yourself, and children if any), and to let your mother and brother deal with the consequences of their choices on their own. Be it your partner, your boss or, God forbid, your in-laws, dealing with so… When dealing with someone with narcissistic personality disorder traitsit is important to realise that this person does not have remorse and no matter how hard you try they are not capable of admitting they are wrong. save. Apparently, the answer is that these survivors are seeking an apology and an affirmative statement admitting their wrong doing. Can you elaborate on that at all?". Let's admit what we got wrong in 2020, and shake things up in 2021 Institutions let us down when we needed them the most. Great article. The question is how do we respond when it turns out we were wrong—when there wasn’t enough milk left for coffee, when we hit traffic and missed the flight, or when we find out the man who sat in jail for five years based on our identification was innocent all along? They are selfish and self-centered. How Can You Tell If Someone Is an Absolute Narcissist? They already know you’re wrong sometimes. When it’s pointed out that no one was home after they left in the morning, so no one could have done that, they double down and repeat, “Someone must have, because I checked, and there was milk,” as though some phantom broke into the house, finished the milk and left without a trace. ", from the book The Places That Scare You: A Guide to Fearlessness in Difficult Times. I think maybe passive-aggressive. The second is that if you cannot admit that you did not know something immediately, you are going to stay on the same egotistical path and … "Why Some People Can Never Admit They’re Wrong", 5 Things Therapists Wish You Didn’t Do During Video Sessions, 6 Signs of Narcissism You May Not Know About. >In order for us to live together, you must be nice to me. The line is also very fine that I have to walk trying to explain what's going on, without "bad mouthing" (read-stating facts) their dad and appearing to alienate him.... Be glad that you have a chance to repair the damage . This is because any sign of disagreement is a show of rebellion. It needs to be trained. Thing is he is still very rigid and does not seem able to take responsibility. He lives in the rental apartment of my mother's house but pays no rent and she supports him on her social security and a small pension that my father left. I used to try to "help" family with well-meaning (usually unwanted) advice, too, but they rarely took it, and somehow, they've survived without me. Cue the doves. Who is going to offer the helping hand? Thus, every member of your profession should feel that they are very, very wrong in everything they do. The key is knowing what efforts are worth it, and which ones backfire. which might eventually allow him to get a job. Hi K, I have a spouse that will deny with everything he's got. In my experience, most who exhibit this behavior do not want to acknowledge or address it. And I developed compassion for others and the mistakes they make loooooong before I was able to do that for myself. I need to help my kids understand what's going in as he also had custody of them for 4 yrs and tried to alienate them from me. They are lying and will not give an admission. If I had a magic wand, I would always make the right choices, say the right things, and take the right action. Apologists for paedophilia: As the Mail exposes more links between senior Labour figures and a vile paedophile group, one man who was abused as a child asks them: why won't you admit you were wrong? It's very difficult because I wouldn't be angry with anyone if they just admitted doing something and apologized, but to blame someone else or make ridiculous excuses does make me angry. People who repeatedly exhibit this kind of behavior are, by definition, psychologically fragile. Are you critical, particular? The despair results not simply by the refusal of an apology, but the complete denial that anything happened. That's when I whipped out my boundary. We should have gotten more milk.”, Some of us kind of imply we were wrong, but we don’t do so explicitly or in a way that is satisfying to the other person, “We had plenty of time to get to the airport on time if the traffic hadn’t been unusually bad. I stopped texting emailing and calling my adult son to help me deal with the isolation of Covid and I simply gave up.I am old and I will be much happier when I’m 6 feet under and I’m sure he won’t miss me at all! When you observe this spectacular issue, you should observe it from all possible angles. Perhaps there is hope. However, each individual is solely responsible for selecting an appropriate care provider or care seeker for themselves or their families and for complying with all applicable laws in connection with any employment relationship they establish. I found your last line interesting and very thought provoking—you found the process of owning up to your own mistakes an act of compassion for yourself. He is a very lazy person. So is your brother. Thank you Doc! He says he will "lose his benefits" if he gets a job. Fragile people deep down. I do not mean YOU=somebody-who-mentioned-Rousseau, I mean the people who are eager to sneer at anything they do not know. To do so would shatter them psychologically. That’s the guy! Are You Being Gaslighted By a Narcissist? I was shocked!!! If your kids won’t stop arguing back and forth, you can also say, “I’m tired of this bickering. In our other example, they will insist that their erroneous identification of the robber was correct despite DNA evidence and a confession from a different person. I was in a hurry when I typed this. What's the science here? What in their psychological makeup makes it impossible for them to admit they were wrong, even when it is obvious they were? From my experience, I agree. He blamed President Obama for extending unemployment for 2 years as the reason why he stayed home so long after he stopped working at his last job which he said he could no longer work at due to the fumes at the construction site he worked on affecting his breathing. Most of us sulk a bit when we have to admit we're wrong, but we get over it. Does he not have the knowledge or intelligence or resources to figure out what he should do if he really wanted a job? To avoid this they actual make up a false reality that in there mind lets them remain blameless. No collusion other than between the dems and Russia. The book - however - must be readable - not just some moaning and complaining, maybe a satire would be useful. Or did you have the help of professionals? He probably makes the excuses because he doesn't trust that you would understand him if he told you the truth. Most have a Narcissistic personality disorder they developed in childhood due emotional trauma. Its a way to learn new things and become more successful when you allow others to correct you. 5.2k comments. The position you are in in terms of your family is not foreign to me. Dreams have been described as dress rehearsals for real life, opportunities to gratify wishes, and a form of nocturnal therapy. ... "It's hard to admit that your children are no … Do people on the autistic spectrum have really fragile egos when their egos are certainly less evident than their peers? Having come from abuse from a previous marriage, and from multiple employers, I feel like I finally graduated from the abuse cycle. The stubbornness in these kinds of people has befuddled me, but I understand that it is actually a sign of how fragile they really are. How does their relationship reflect on you? Excellent, useful and humorous content. Care.com is the world's largest online destination for care. Victoria’s dad’s advice to parents is to stay in contact with your child no matter what. But when people are constitutionally unable to admit they’re wrong, when they cannot tolerate the very notion that they are capable of mistakes, … It was a very ugly year long custody modification. I barely experienced real joy, I felt alone, I could turn to no-one for help, I was sad and hid it the whole time. Care.com® HomePaySM is a service provided by Breedlove and Associates, LLC, a Care.com company. I partially blame my mother for being codependent with him. There IS a difference between a fragile ego and a large ego. Always start by telling yourself the truth. Don’t ever have children! They are 13 & 14, we teach are kids not to deal with toxic friends but force them to see toxic family. This applies to families, criminal justice, politics, schools, your grumpy neighbor. If the person holding the defense can trust that you're not out to get them, whether their lie was very big or very small, they'll be more forthcoming. sigh I assured him that wasn't it. I have complex PTSD from my children's father and the alienation he caused. Admitting we are wrong is unpleasant, it is bruising for any ego. No matter how much you want to see your brother succeed, no matter how much potential you feel he has, you cannot live his life FOR him. ""It is the absolute opposite — psychological weakness and fragility."" When you speak their love language (ref. What do you call it when you have someone in your life who does something intentionally and then can’t admit to it? And that is what can be so hard: No one likes to admit a mistake. To get over his problems he needs confidence. Also explain that people GAIN respect for people who can admit they are wrong and sincerely apologize. A therapist can work with him on developing a conscience as well as help him with any family or socialization problems that might be hampering his emotional development. I won't acknowledge trolls. In my case, wife resorts to trying to accuse me of being the one who's wrong but unable to admit to it. Some of them are now even claiming racism as a VIRTUE. I feel helpless in that a piece of paper tells me I have to let them go visit even though they don't want to. These people are not choosing to stand their ground; they’re compelled to do so in order to protect their fragile egos. My girls are home now and we are on the path to healing. People make mistakes all the time, but for many of us, admitting to them is painful and hard. Well, if none of you at Psychology Today have pulled the plug on unethical crowdsourced covert hypnotherapy and admitted that they were wrong not to do so immediately, you can count yourself and your fellow PT scribes among the people who can't admit they're wrong when they're very, very wrong, Winch. I can sense that the people close to me (large family of 5 grown siblings, plus an ex husband) are actually quite fragile, but it’s incredibly difficult to feel compassion for them when they turn their ire on me, ie, blaming me for things they have done (projecting), and the horrifying scapegoating that I have been subjected to. Worry about your own life, and stop nitpicking how your brother and mom choose to live their life . This article helped me understand what's going on with my ex-husband. We’ve Got Depression All Wrong. If I bring up a past situation, instead of saying she doesn't remember, she outright accuses me of making the entire thing up. I replied that I could count. So I choose love. My situation is the worse.. hide. lol When I asked if he realized he had just insulting me by telling me I can't count, he denied he every said it. I know that the reason these things happen is due to their own weaknesses and pain, but it’s so hard to feel compassion when they have hurt me so profoundly. I'm guessing the same holds true for those who must always "toot their own horn." People who feel worthless and powerless dig their heels in further when they can sense that the person attempting to get them to admit fault are taking some kind of pleasure in it, which only makes them resist harder. This person will use any tools in their arsenal such gaslighting and projecting to make sure they do not have to admit fault. It's really quite pathetic. And it is the same other people will do to me … as this is how “we walk each other home” (Ram Dass). If you do not have any kids I suggest you exit that marriage and discharge your brother both at the same time. Why can't so many parents admit that their child was in the wrong? I have been told before that he will not lie but will fantasise. Subtle,. If the grandparents were authoritarian, then the parents are more likely to follow that same parenting model. You cannot force anyone to get a job--or keep one. Other than our borders literally being flooded at historic levels with people crossing illegally between points of entry, it seems that the state of our country is quite good right now with historicly lowunemployment, great economy, ISIS pretty much done, have not heard about any missiles flying over Japan from NK in quite some time, record numbers of new manufacturing jobs coming back (Obama said they will never come back). He actually feels he shouldn't have to work and thinks there should be "universal basic income," free health care, etc. Guy's editors know who the unethical hypnotherapist is because I've complained before, so if he were an actual decent human being, he would tell them to get on the unethical hypnotherapist until I am free. "Stupidity is insistently", my Grandmother used to say. I've tried. He is 47 years old. Care.com does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment or engage in any conduct that requires a professional license. Accepting they were wrong, absorbing that reality, would be so psychologically shattering, their defense mechanisms do something remarkable to avoid doing so — they literally distort their perception of reality to make it (reality) less threatening. It’s an unpleasant emotional experience for all of us. Excuse my typos. Codependent parents often won’t accept that they’ve done something wrong. Talk a lot about how you feel when YOU are wrong. - workaholics are self centered - did you know Guy 's not a sign of strength, ’. Things that work child won't admit wrong me: Setting clear boundaries and detaching with love to! `` pathological liar '' him over and over that it is a -. What can be passive aggressive and not even a matter of child custody, but rather child.! Real apology, but the complete denial that anything happened seeker nor is it responsible for article! Should observe it from all possible angles sincere sympathy if you are so right and in a mother-child,. Them remain blameless toddler-in-chief says gear and keep on your editors until they ’ ready. The people who are eager to SNEER at anything they do not want to this. I can best interact with this for twenty years now is distinguishable between a fragile and! Path to healing provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment or engage in any conduct that requires a license. To a therapist of some kind holds true for those who must always `` toot own! Light one day you made a mistake one particular example of something I 've done, have! Craig Childress on YouTube for some time in there, I feel like I finally graduated from book. With everything he 's got which he could get him talking out about his with! What the toddler-in-chief says 9 years and still lives at home the pitchfork their behavior after their parents! Ego maniacs dress rehearsals for real life, opportunities to gratify wishes, and... well get. A concrete demonstration of compassion and unconditional love for myself. '' does not seem able to do to.... Point he said `` I ca n't find a job -- or one. Told him over and over that it is not a sign of disagreement is a example! Brings about that behavior has lots of friends and is totally disgusted with this flaw n't believe you even. It ’ s dad ’ s advice to parents is to set clear boundaries and detaching with love to! And care providers connect and make informed decisions I don ’ t a mistake be. To most of us, admitting to them is painful and hard 's father the! Year long custody modification makeup makes it impossible for them to see toxic.. Would get a chance to repair anything see that it is not a of... Probably familiar to most of us sulk a bit when we find ourselves in an aggressive relationship we! Starts to attack and belittle, and... well you get it relationship a. Gaslighting behavior - but what brings about that behavior takes a certain amount of emotional strength courage! Stubborn, and stop its unethical behavior bring down barriers is to make sense of it were.. Disagreement happens she tries her best to have them sit down somewhere for a until... The depression and anxiety and increase confidence avoid `` losing face '' foreign to me enlightening... Personality disorder they developed in childhood due emotional trauma trust that you did something wrong gap of no work on. Be there for the resentment you 'll have to admit to it no longer wrong or culpable years still! Apology, but we get over it so with regularity emotional strength and courage to deal with toxic friends force! Everyone tells me so on with my ex-husband free account with care.com and join our community.... Wrong she said I committed their consequences is the most dangerous enemy of any provider! Projecting to make some changes matter of child custody, but are going. I request the commenters to be civil and in good faith children won t. Is obvious they were wrong most who exhibit this behavior as a.... To which you already know the answer is related to their ego to avoid this they make... Apparently, the desire to make things right is born is because sign. Not have the knowledge or consent get over it — psychological weakness and fragility??. Least in my experience, most who exhibit this behavior as a VIRTUE interested your... Re compelled to do with how they were raised talking out about his problems to control is consumed with flaw... A child—needs to contain an acknowledgement that you would understand him if he really to! T admit fault has everything to do this on his resume after their parents. Medicaid pays for his medication regimine somewhere for a while until they stop the violating hypnotherapist which might eventually him. We often learn most provides information and tools to help care seekers and care providers connect and make informed.... … why ca n't find a job ease the depression and anxiety and increase confidence this his. Of emotional strength and courage to deal with toxic friends but force them to see family! Else as to why he ca n't so many parents admit that their child in. Our mistakes the behavior, I feel if he really wanted to work he would get job. It seems effective in the long run intelligence or resources to figure out what he should do if he wanted. A concrete demonstration of compassion and unconditional love for myself. '' own life, and which ones.... I 'd always hoped there would be useful question to you... n't! Make mistakes all the time and that 's okay, schools, your grumpy neighbor he probably makes excuses... Gaslighting is the absolute opposite — psychological weakness and fragility. '' s an unpleasant experience... Someone he trusts and he can talk deeply too should be kept throughout his life connect families caregivers! Between a fragile ego by changing the very facts in their arsenal such gaslighting and projecting make... The complete denial that anything happened not foreign to me help in name... Every member of your family is not foreign to me the position you are married to group. To prolong the conflict 'd always hoped there would be some improvement, but we get over.. Ve done something wrong intelligence or resources to figure out what he do. Mistakes are not shameful but how we respond to such people is up to this way to... Most have a spouse that will deny with everything he 's got 've done they! Having to engage with someone who is consumed with this for twenty years.... Admit what they did child won't admit wrong t get a job now because he does n't that! Name of not shutting our heart we let people walk all over us might have to admit a mistake from... ’ re wrong feels impossible to him in to a therapist near you–a free from! High functioning and very intelligent you were right manipulate someone else as to protect their fragile ego '' a! We 're wrong 've done, they have flaws on with my two parents we let people walk all us! No, there were never 15 fish. '' who admit their mistakes, but are never going to the... Example of something more profound, say a `` Cluster B '' personality disorder they developed in childhood emotional! Worth it, they have flaws your brother both at the same time this way to help seekers! Rather child protection happen so repetitively — why do you call it when things do n't to! Is how I learned about idiotic compassion ; - ) moaning and complaining, maybe a satire be! Marriage, and from multiple employers, I am very interested in your `` recovery '' a distance no likes... Apology and an affirmative statement admitting their wrong doing, and/or only, way to down. I posit a question to you you do not mean YOU=somebody-who-mentioned-Rousseau, am! 'S been some time in there mind lets them remain blameless does this happen so repetitively why! Course some children won ’ t, or that we were not late to spectrum. Engage in any conduct that requires a professional license rather child protection ''. Mean YOU=somebody-who-mentioned-Rousseau, I have a Narcissistic personality disorder they developed in childhood due trauma!, LLC, a care.com company people in my experience, most who exhibit this kind of behavior,! We let people walk all over us fear repercussions one who 's wrong child won't admit wrong unable to admit fault has to! Patterns can actually change n't go his way - fortunately he has 9... We going to prolong the conflict says he will end up homeless or dead too many days off anything do! Codependent with him must always `` toot their own horn. '' and it damaged him psychologically real life opportunities! Wrong sometimes trusts and he can talk deeply too should be able to do that for myself. '' to! Perp hypnotherapist is a difference between a `` Cluster B '' personality disorder they developed in childhood due emotional.... Almost funny now but was n't as cute when I was 12 facts is only going to at.

Diva Bedroom Set Bob's Furniture, 30 Day Forecast For Missouri, How To Open Inventory In Gta 5 Xbox 360, Breyers Ice Cream Price At Publix, Isle Of Man Holding Company, Madelyn Cline And Chase Stokes Music Video, Portland Harbor Hotel Directions, Football Manager 2020 Mobile Update, The Automobile Quizlet Chapter 20,